Offsetting Perceptions: Firms Use Charitable Giving To Clean Up Their International Reputation
Release Date 02 April 2009
British multinationals operating in countries that lack basic human rights give around 70% more money to charity than firms that do not have a presence in such politically controversial nations, a new study by researchers at the University of Reading's Henley Business School and the University of Bath has revealed.
The findings support the growing body of research suggesting that corporate charitable giving plays an important strategic role for many businesses.
In a study looking at the charitable donations of 305 UK plcs, comprising around half of FTSE All-Share Index companies, analysts found that a corporate presence in one or more countries in which political rights and civil liberties are curtailed pushed up the average level of donations from £1.148m to £1.977m.
Writing in the Journal of Management Studies, the researchers suggest that this increased philanthropy could be seen as an attempt to "offset" negative connotations related to the companies' operations in controversial countries such as China, Burma, Sudan and the Democratic Republic of Congo.
"The positive impact on charitable giving is restricted to a presence in only those countries that are most lacking in political rights and civil liberties," said Dr Stephen Pavelin, of Henley Business School, UK, part of the team who carried out the research. "Our findings suggest that companies are seeking to offset negative impressions in the eyes of the public that arise from doing business in such countries by making greater gifts to charity."
The study drew information from the companies' annual reports from 2002 and looked at presence in 'countries of concern', as defined by criteria established by the FTSE4Good Index – which aims to identify environmentally and socially responsible companies – as well as indicators of political rights, civil liberties and corruption derived from research by the independent organisations Freedom House and Transparency International.
Unable to separate out corporate giving by country, the team could not determine whether the higher levels of charitable donations were directed towards projects in the UK or in the host countries themselves. "This finding is perhaps indicative of relatively token responses to corporate exposure to political and civil rights issues, rather than significant attempts to address or atone for these issues through giving aimed at impacted communities," said Dr Pavelin.
While political and civil rights issues were shown to stimulate charitable donations, level of corruption did not have a similar effect. "It appears that the salient feature of a country in this connection is a lack of political rights and/or civil liberties, rather than a presence of high levels of corruption," said Dr Pavelin.
No evidence was found of a link between money donated to charity and the fact that firms operated in a number of different countries. Multinationals make similar contributions to their 'uni-national' counterparts, the study found.
"It is clear that the characteristics of the countries within which companies operate play a more significant role in shaping corporate social performance than the degree of internationalisation per se," said Dr Pavelin.
Further information from the Univesity of Reading on 0118 378 7388
Notes to editors:
Henley Business School at the University of Reading
• One of the Europe's largest full-service business schools, Henley Business School at the University of Reading is also one of the few global business schools to hold triple accredited status (AMBA, EQUIS, AACSB).
• The School comprises five distinctive units - the Schools of Economics, Management and Real Estate & Planning, the ICMA Centre and a world-renowned executive education division.
• Henley Business School's internationally renowned offering includes an established range of undergraduate and postgraduate degrees, the world-ranked Henley MBA and leading-edge open and customised executive programmes. The School attracts students and programme members from over 140 countries.
Journal of Management Studies.
Media wishing to receive a PDF of this article may contact - firstname.lastname@example.org
Brammer S.J., Pavelin S., Porter L.A.; Corporate charitable giving, multinational companies and countries of concern; Journal of Management Studies 2009; DOI; 10.1111/j.1467-6486.2008.00827.x
About the authors
Stephen Pavelin is a Reader in Economics at Henley Business School, University of Reading, UK. To arrange an interview, please the contact University of Reading press office on +44(0)118 3787388
Stephen J. Brammer is a Senior Lecturer, and Deputy Director of the Centre for Business Organizations and Society, at the University of Bath, UK.
Lynda A. Porter is a Lecturer in Economics at Henley Business School, University of Reading, UK.
About the Journal of Management Studies
International in scope and readership, the Journal of Management Studies is a multidisciplinary journal, publishing articles on organization theory and behaviour, strategic and human resource management - from empirical studies and theoretical developments to practical applications.